Duties, Rights & Disabilities of a Trustee; the Beneficiary — Transfer of Property Notes

Duties and Liabilities of Trustees

Accepting a trust is easy; discharging it is exacting. The Act loads a trustee with duties designed around one idea — he manages another’s property, so he must be as careful, honest and impartial as if it were watched every day.

The Trustee’s Duties (Sections 11–30)

The principal duties of a trustee:

Execute the trust (s.11) — carry out the trust according to its terms and the directions of the author, except where varied by consent of competent beneficiaries.
Acquaint himself with the trust property (s.12) — inform himself of the state and amount of the trust-property and get it into his control.
Protect the title (s.13) — maintain and defend all suits and take steps to preserve the trust-property.
Not set up an adverse title (s.14) — he must not deny or set up a title adverse to the beneficiary.
Reasonable care (s.15) — deal with the trust-property as carefully as a person of ordinary prudence would deal with his own; he is not liable for loss if he acted with such care.
Convert perishable property (s.16) and be impartial (s.17) among beneficiaries; prevent waste (s.18).
Keep accounts and give information (s.19) — maintain clear accounts and furnish information to the beneficiary on request.
Invest trust-money (s.20) — invest only in the securities authorised by the Act or the instrument.

Liability for breach of trust (s.23). Where a trustee commits a breach of trust, he is liable to make good the loss which the trust-property or the beneficiary has thereby sustained — with interest in appropriate cases. He cannot set off a gain in one part of the trust against a loss in another (s.24), and several trustees are jointly and severally liable for a breach they joined in.

Section 15, Indian Trusts Act: “A trustee is bound to deal with the trust-property as carefully as a man of ordinary prudence would deal with such property if it were his own; and, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, a trustee so dealing is not responsible for the loss, destruction or deterioration of the trust-property.”

In Simple Terms: A trustee must carry out the trust, know and protect the property, never claim it against the beneficiary, act with a prudent person’s care, stay impartial, keep honest accounts and invest safely. If he breaks the trust, he must personally make good the loss.

🧩 WORKED EXAMPLE — the careless investment

Facts. T, a trustee, puts the trust-money into a speculative venture not authorised by the deed, and it is lost.

Rule. Sections 15, 20 and 23 — a trustee must act with a prudent person’s care and invest only in authorised securities; a breach makes him liable to make good the loss.

Apply. T invested in an unauthorised, imprudent venture — a breach of ss.15 and 20.

Conclusion. T is liable to restore the lost trust-money to the trust (with interest where appropriate).

flowchart TD
    A["Trustee's duties (ss.11-30)"]
    A --> B["Execute trust; know & protect property; not set up adverse title"]
    A --> C["Ordinary-prudence care (s.15); impartial; prevent waste"]
    A --> D["Keep accounts (s.19); invest safely (s.20)"]
    A --> E["Breach (s.23): make good the loss"]
    classDef box fill:#e8f0fe,stroke:#333,color:#111;
    class A,B,C,D,E box;

Case Laws

Speight v Gaunt (1883) — a trustee must conduct the trust’s business with the same care an ordinarily prudent person would use in his own affairs; honest and prudent conduct excuses a loss.

Rights and Powers of Trustees

The law that binds a trustee with duties also arms him with rights and powers — he cannot manage a trust with his hands tied. But every power is a power to be used for the trust, never for himself.

Rights and Powers (Sections 31–45)

Rights of a trustee:

Right to the title-deeds (s.31) — to have in his possession the instrument of trust and the documents of title.
Right to reimbursement of expenses (s.32) — to be reimbursed, out of the trust-property, all expenses properly incurred in executing the trust, preserving the property or protecting the beneficiary; he has a lien on the trust-property for such expenses.
Right to indemnity from a gainer by breach (s.33) and to apply to the court for opinion, advice or direction (s.34) on the management of the trust.
Right to a discharge on the completion of his duties (s.35).

Powers of a trustee:

General power of management (s.36) — to do all acts reasonable and proper for the realisation, protection or benefit of the trust-property and the beneficiary.
Power to sell (s.37) — where authorised, to sell the trust-property, in lots, by public auction or private contract, together or in parcels.
Power to convey (s.39), to vary investments (s.40), to apply property of a minor for maintenance (s.41), to give receipts (s.42), and to compound/compromise claims (s.43).

Powers are held jointly by co-trustees (they must act together — s.48) and must be exercised for the benefit of the trust, never for the trustee’s own gain.

Section 32, Indian Trusts Act (part): “Every trustee may reimburse himself, or pay or discharge out of the trust-property, all expenses properly incurred in or about the execution of the trust, or the realisation, preservation or benefit of the trust-property, or the protection or support of the beneficiary.”

In Simple Terms: A trustee has the right to hold the title-deeds, to be repaid his proper expenses out of the trust (with a lien for them), and to ask the court for directions. He has powers to manage, sell, invest, give receipts and settle claims — but always jointly with co-trustees and only for the trust’s benefit.

🧩 WORKED EXAMPLE — reimbursing repair costs

Facts. T, a trustee, spends his own money on urgent repairs to the trust building to preserve it.

Rule. Section 32 — a trustee may reimburse himself out of the trust-property for expenses properly incurred in preserving it, with a lien for them.

Apply. The repairs were a proper preservation expense.

Conclusion. T may recoup the repair cost from the trust-property and has a lien on it until repaid.

flowchart TD
    A["Trustee's rights & powers (ss.31-45)"]
    A --> B["Rights: title-deeds (s.31); reimbursement + lien (s.32); court's advice (s.34); discharge (s.35)"]
    A --> C["Powers: manage (s.36); sell (s.37); vary investments (s.40); receipts (s.42); compromise (s.43)"]
    A --> D["Exercised jointly (s.48), only for the trust"]
    classDef box fill:#e8f0fe,stroke:#333,color:#111;
    class A,B,C,D box;

Case Laws

The rule of s.32 — a trustee has a right of reimbursement and a lien over the trust-property for expenses properly incurred in realising, preserving or benefiting the trust.

Disabilities of a Trustee

The most important rule for a trustee is a “cannot” — he cannot make a profit out of his position. Everything he does with the trust must be for the beneficiary, not himself. The disabilities are the law’s fence around that principle.

Disabilities of a Trustee (Sections 46–54)

A trustee is under several disabilities — things he cannot do:

Cannot renounce after acceptance (s.46) — having accepted the trust, he cannot throw it up except with the court’s permission, the consent of the beneficiary (competent to contract), or under a power in the instrument.
Cannot delegate (s.47) — delegatus non potest delegare [a delegate cannot further delegate]; a trustee must perform his duties personally and cannot delegate them except where the instrument or the ordinary course of business allows.
Co-trustees cannot act singly (s.48) — all must join in the execution of the trust; one cannot act for the others without authority.
Cannot use trust-property for his own profit (s.51) — he must not use or deal with the trust-property for his own benefit or that of anyone but the beneficiary.
Cannot buy the trust-property (s.52) — a trustee (or his agent) may not buy, on his own account, any part of the trust-property, because his duty (to sell dear) conflicts with his interest (to buy cheap).
Cannot buy the beneficiary’s interest without permission (s.53) and cannot act where interest and duty conflict.

The thread through all these is the no-conflict, no-profit rule: a trustee must never place himself in a position where his personal interest competes with his duty to the beneficiary.

Section 51, Indian Trusts Act: “A trustee may not use or deal with the trust-property for his own profit or for any other purpose unconnected with the trust.”

In Simple Terms: A trustee cannot back out once he accepts, cannot pass his job to someone else, cannot act alone if there are co-trustees, and above all cannot profit from the trust — he cannot buy the trust-property or the beneficiary’s interest. His interest must never clash with his duty.

🧩 WORKED EXAMPLE — the trustee who buys the trust land

Facts. T, trustee to sell trust-land for the beneficiary, sells it to himself at the market price.

Rule. Section 52 — a trustee may not buy the trust-property on his own account; the no-conflict rule makes the purchase voidable at the beneficiary’s instance, however fair the price.

Apply. T’s duty was to get the best price for the beneficiary; buying it himself puts his interest against that duty.

Conclusion. The sale to T is voidable at the beneficiary’s option, even though the price was fair.

flowchart TD
    A["Disabilities (ss.46-54): the no-profit / no-conflict fence"]
    A --> B["No renunciation after acceptance (s.46)"]
    A --> C["No delegation (s.47); co-trustees act jointly (s.48)"]
    A --> D["No profit from trust (s.51)"]
    A --> E["Cannot buy trust-property (s.52) or beneficiary's interest (s.53)"]
    classDef box fill:#e8f0fe,stroke:#333,color:#111;
    class A,B,C,D,E box;

Case Laws

Keech v Sandford (1726) — a trustee may not profit from the trust; any gain made from his position is held for the beneficiary (the foundation of the no-profit rule).

Rights and Liabilities of the Beneficiary

The whole point of a trust is the beneficiary — the cestui que trust. He does not hold the legal title, but equity gives him a powerful set of rights to make the trustee do his duty and to follow the property if it is misapplied.

Rights of the Beneficiary (Sections 55–69)

The beneficiary (cestui que trust) is the person for whose benefit the trust exists. His principal rights:

Right to rents and profits (s.55) — to receive the rents and profits of the trust-property, subject to the terms of the trust.
Right to specific execution (s.56) — to have the intention of the author specifically executed to the extent of his interest, and to have the property properly protected and administered.
Right to inspect and take copies (s.57) — of the instrument of trust, the accounts and documents.
Right to transfer his beneficial interest (s.58) — a competent beneficiary may transfer his interest, subject to the law.
Right to sue for execution of the trust (s.59) where no trustee is appointed, and to a proper trustee (s.60).
Right to compel the trustee to perform any particular act of his duty (s.61) and to restrain a breach.
Right to follow trust-property (s.63) — to trace and recover the trust-property (or its proceeds) into the hands of third parties who are not bona fide transferees for value without notice; and against a wrongful purchaser (s.62).

Liabilities of the beneficiary (ss.66–68). A beneficiary who joins in a breach of trust, or obtains an advantage from it without the others’ consent, or otherwise becomes a party to it, may be liable to indemnify the trustee to the extent of his interest, and his own interest may be impounded to make good the loss.

Section 56, Indian Trusts Act (part): “The beneficiary has, subject to the provisions of the instrument of trust, a right that the intention of the author of the trust shall be specifically executed to the extent of the beneficiary’s interest.”

In Simple Terms: The beneficiary is the person the trust is for. He can claim the income, force the trustee to carry out and properly administer the trust, inspect the accounts, transfer his interest, and even trace the property if it is wrongly sold — except into the hands of an innocent buyer for value. But if he joins in a breach or profits from it, he must make good his share of the loss.

🧩 WORKED EXAMPLE — following the misapplied property

Facts. Trustee T wrongfully sells trust-land to X, who buys knowing of the trust. The beneficiary B wants the land back.

Rule. Section 63 — a beneficiary may follow and recover trust-property in the hands of a transferee who is not a bona fide purchaser for value without notice.

Apply. X bought with notice of the trust, so he is not protected; B may trace the property to X.

Conclusion. B may recover the land from X (or its proceeds), because X took with notice of the trust.

flowchart TD
    A["Beneficiary (cestui que trust) — ss.55-69"]
    A --> B["Rights: rents & profits (s.55); specific execution (s.56); inspect (s.57); transfer interest (s.58)"]
    A --> C["Compel duty / restrain breach (s.61); follow property (s.63)"]
    A --> D["Liability: joining in a breach — indemnify trustee, interest impounded (ss.66-68)"]
    classDef box fill:#e8f0fe,stroke:#333,color:#111;
    class A,B,C,D box;

Case Laws

Official Trustee v Sachindra Nath Chatterjee (1969) — the beneficiary’s interest is protected: a settlor may vary a trust only in the manner the trust-deed permits, and the beneficiary can compel due administration of the trust.

Vacating Office and Extinction of Trusts

A trust does not last forever. When its purpose is done, or becomes unlawful or impossible, or the beneficiary lets it go, the trust ends and the property is freed. And a trustee’s own connection to the office ends by death, discharge or removal.

Vacating the Office of Trustee (Sections 70–72)

The office of a trustee is vacated by his death or by his discharge (s.70). A trustee may be discharged (s.71) by: the extinction of the trust; the completion of his duties; consent of all the beneficiaries (competent to contract); the appointment under the Act of a new trustee in his place; a court order on his petition (s.72). A trustee wishing to be discharged may petition the court (s.72). He cannot simply abandon the office (recall s.46).

Extinction of a Trust (Sections 77–78)

A trust is extinguished (s.77) when:

its purpose is completely fulfilled;
its purpose becomes unlawful;
the fulfilment of its purpose becomes impossible (e.g. by destruction of the trust-property); or
the trust, being revocable, is revoked.

Revocation of a trust (s.78). A trust created by will may be revoked at the author’s pleasure. A trust otherwise created can be revoked only: (a) where all the beneficiaries are competent to contract and consent; (b) where the trust was created for the payment of the author’s debts and has not been communicated to the creditors, by the author; or (c) where a power of revocation was expressly reserved to the author.

Section 77, Indian Trusts Act: “A trust is extinguished — (a) when its purpose is completely fulfilled; or (b) when its purpose becomes unlawful; or (c) when the fulfilment of its purpose becomes impossible by destruction of the trust-property or otherwise; or (d) when the trust, being revocable, is revoked.”

In Simple Terms: A trustee’s office ends by death or discharge (he cannot just walk away — he needs the beneficiaries’ consent, a new trustee, or the court). A trust itself ends when its job is done, or becomes unlawful or impossible, or is revoked — and it can be revoked only on limited grounds (all beneficiaries consent, a debt-trust not yet communicated to creditors, or a reserved power).

🧩 WORKED EXAMPLE — purpose fulfilled

Facts. A trust was created to hold a fund and pay for D’s education. D completes her education and the fund is exhausted on it.

Rule. Section 77(a) — a trust is extinguished when its purpose is completely fulfilled.

Apply. The sole purpose (paying for D’s education) is fully accomplished and the property applied.

Conclusion. The trust is extinguished; the trustee’s office ends and he is entitled to a discharge.

flowchart TD
    A["Extinction of trust (s.77)"]
    A --> B["Purpose completely fulfilled"]
    A --> C["Purpose becomes unlawful"]
    A --> D["Fulfilment becomes impossible (property destroyed)"]
    A --> E["Revocable trust is revoked (s.78)"]
    classDef box fill:#e8f0fe,stroke:#333,color:#111;
    class A,B,C,D,E box;

Case Laws

Allcard v Skinner (1887) — a trust/gift may be revoked or set aside on established equitable grounds; absent such grounds a completed trust stands until extinguished under s.77.

📄 Full notes + Question Bank (₹199) — every topic in depth, model answers to all past KSLU questions, in one printable PDF. Get the bundle · 10 Solved Problems · All Transfer of Property topics