Section 8 — How a Male Hindu's Estate Devolves — Hindu Law (Family Law I) Notes

Succession of a Male Hindu Dying Intestate

In Anar Devi v. Parmeshwari Devi (2006), the Supreme Court clarified the interplay between Class I heirs and coparcenary interest — a landmark on how the Schedule operates in practice. This case reminds us: in the exam’s problem questions, always identify the class of each heir first, then apply the share rules.

Section 8 — Devolution of Male Hindu’s Intestate Property

General rule: The property of a male Hindu dying intestate devolves according to the provisions of Sections 8–13.

Priority order:

1. Class I heirs — simultaneous; they share equally (per capita among entries; per stirpes within entries).
2. Class II heirs — in order of entries; earlier entry excludes later.
3. Agnates — related by blood or adoption through males only.
4. Cognates — related by blood or adoption (through males or females).
5. Government (by escheat [lapse to the state]) — if no heirs at all.

Class I Heirs (Section 8 read with Schedule)

The Schedule to the HSA lists Class I heirs:

Key rules for Class I:

• All Class I heirs take simultaneously — no preference among them.
• Each heir takes one share (per capita) — except that the widow(s) together take one share.
• If a son has predeceased the intestate, his children (son/daughter) and widow collectively take what the predeceased son would have taken (per stirpes [by branch]).
• If multiple widows of the intestate, they collectively take one share.

Important Problem-Solving Rule

When solving a succession problem:

1. List all relatives mentioned.
2. Identify who falls under Class I.
3. If any Class I heir exists, only Class I heirs take — all others are excluded.
4. Divide the property among Class I heirs equally (per capita per entry; per stirpes within each entry for predeceased persons’ branch).

Example (Jan 2026 PYQ): A male Hindu dies intestate leaving father-in-law, father, brother, sister, and son.

• Father-in-law: not an heir.
• Father: Class II, Entry 1 (but excluded if Class I exists).
• Brother: Class II, Entry 2 (excluded if Class I or Class II Entry 1 exists).
• Sister: Class II, Entry 2.
• Son: Class I heir — he alone takes the entire estate. All others are excluded.

Answer: Son takes the entire estate.

flowchart TD
    ROOT["Male Hindu Dies Intestate"]:::root
    ROOT --> A["Class I Heirs Present?<br/>(Son, Daughter, Widow,<br/>Mother, etc.)"]:::q
    A -- YES --> B["Class I heirs share equally<br/>(per capita; per stirpes<br/>for predeceased branch)"]:::yes
    A -- NO --> C["Class II Heirs?<br/>(Father, Son's daughter, etc.<br/>in order of entries)"]:::q
    C -- YES --> D["Earliest entry takes;<br/>excludes later entries"]:::yes
    C -- NO --> E["Agnates → Cognates<br/>→ Government (escheat)"]:::last

    classDef root fill:#FFF8DC,stroke:#333,stroke-width:1px,color:#000;
    classDef q fill:#FFFFF0,stroke:#333,color:#000;
    classDef yes fill:#E6F3FF,stroke:#1E3A8A,color:#000;
    classDef last fill:#FFE6E6,stroke:#8A1E1E,color:#000;
    linkStyle default stroke:#888,stroke-width:1px;

🚨 FACT-PATTERN RISK ALERT (Succession Problem)

Scenario: Rahul, a Hindu male, dies intestate leaving his mother, brother, two sons, and widow. How does his estate devolve?

• I — ISSUE: Who are the heirs and what are their shares in Rahul’s intestate estate under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956?
• R — RULE: S.8, HSA 1956 — Class I heirs take first; they share per capita. Mother, widow, and sons are all Class I heirs. Brother is Class II.
• A — ANALYSIS: Class I heirs present: mother (1 share), widow (1 share), son 1 (1 share), son 2 (1 share) — total 4 shares. Brother is Class II — excluded entirely. Decoy: do not split widow’s share if there is only one widow.
• C — CONCLUSION: Estate divided into 4 equal shares: Mother = 1/4, Widow = 1/4, Son 1 = 1/4, Son 2 = 1/4.

Back to Top

📄 Full notes + Question Bank (₹199) — every topic in depth, model answers to all past KSLU questions, in one printable PDF. Get the bundle · 10 Solved Problems · All Hindu Law topics